Authority & Link Building · Guide

Link building starts with analysis, not outreach.

Analysis first means finding out what authority your competitors have earned, and you haven't, before any outreach starts. It matters for search because Google uses links as a signal, and because working out which links matter is a different job from collecting more of them.

Talk to an SEO specialist More on Authority & Link Building

Competitor backlink analysis

Google has no documentation on analysing competitors' links, so we will not attribute a method to it. Its Links report in Search Console covers links to your own property: top linked pages, top linking sites and the most common link text. Data about other sites' links has to come from elsewhere.

Google's documentation does tell you what to be careful about when reading any list of links. Links marked sponsored, ugc or nofollow will, according to its guidance on qualifying outbound links, generally not be followed. And the Links report help says that for known spam sites Google typically ignores the links. So a raw count of a competitor's links is not a count of links that do anything. That is our inference from those two statements, not a Google claim about any competitor.

What the analysis looks for is a matter of judgement: where the links come from, why those sites linked, and whether the reason is something you could credibly match.

Even your own data is summarised. The Links report groups sites by root domain, leaves out subdomains, and combines duplicate link text. Any comparison with another source should allow for differences in how links are counted and grouped. The useful output of this stage is a set of reasons, not a list of domains.

Source: Google Search Central: Qualify Outbound Links for SEO

Link gap analysis

A link gap is the difference between the sites that point to competitors and the sites that point to you. Google has no page on it. It does give a way to read your side of the comparison. The Links report help page suggests checking whether sites important to you point to your site, with a restaurant mentioned in food blogs and review sites as its example, and checking that the link text other sites use describes you accurately.

The gap on its own is a list, and a list invites volume. The useful question is why a site linked to a competitor and not to you: a resource you lack, a story you haven't told, a relationship you haven't built. Some gaps are not worth closing. A site that exists to sell links, or a directory that takes anyone, offers the kinds of links the spam policies describe.

Anything found in the gap should survive the same test as any other link: would it exist if search engines did not?

The report's top linking sites table is sorted by count of links, and count is not quality. The help page suggests confirming that you recognise the sites listed. If unknown and possibly spammy sites appear, it says you might need to ask to be removed or, if all else fails, disavow them. The gap analysis and the clean-up are separate pieces of work.

Source: Google Search Central: Spam Policies for Google Web Search

Authority development plan

Google's SEO Starter Guide says other sites linking to you happens naturally over time, and that you can encourage people to discover your content by promoting your site. That is as close as Google gets to a plan, and it is deliberately general.

A plan built from the gap sets out which links are worth pursuing, in what order, and how to tell whether they worked. For some sites it also means looking back. If past link building needs reviewing, Google's disavow help page is clear about the order of things. It calls the tool advanced, says most sites will not need it, and says to use it only where there are a considerable number of spammy, artificial or low-quality links and they have caused, or are likely to cause, a manual action. It recommends removing as many bad links from the web as possible first.

Measurement uses the same Links report, bearing in mind that it shows links found over time and does not flag nofollow. We report on relevance and outcomes, not domain metrics.

Clean-up is slow. Google says disavowed links continue to be shown in the Links report, that a list applies only to the property it was uploaded to, and that it can take a few weeks for a list to be incorporated. A plan should allow for that lag. We don't promise rankings or traffic numbers. We set out the opportunity and the evidence, and measure against it.

Source: Search Console Help: Disavow links to your site

What Cultured Digital covers: Analysis first

Analysis first is one of the methods in our Authority & Link Building service. We cover competitor backlink analysis, link gap analysis and an authority development plan.

Our campaigns begin with the gap: who links to competitors, and why not to you. Next come the angle (what you can credibly offer that is worth linking to), outreach and review. We set no monthly link quotas and no domain-metric targets. Reviewing past link building is one of the situations this service fits. SEO Strategy is where to find out whether authority is the constraint, and the other methods are digital PR, content-led acquisition and relationship-led outreach.

This is a good fit when the site is sound but competitors have stronger authority, when you have something worth covering and no outreach capacity, when past link building needs reviewing, or when an agency wants a specialist behind its campaigns. We do not promise rankings or traffic numbers: we set out the opportunity and the evidence, and measure against it. A single editorial link from a publication your customers read is worth more than a pile from places they never visit.

Questions

Analysis first: questions answered.

Can Search Console show me my competitors' backlinks?

The Links report covers links to your own property. Data about other sites' links has to come from elsewhere, and Google has no documentation on competitor backlink analysis.

Should we disavow links as part of a link audit?

Only in particular circumstances. Google says most sites will not need the tool, and that it should be used only when there are a considerable number of spammy, artificial or low-quality links that have caused or are likely to cause a manual action.

Does a link gap analysis mean you will close the gap link by link?

No. We don't work to quotas or domain-metric targets. The analysis sets out where the authority gap is and what is credibly worth pursuing.

Do links help with AI search?

Credible references in the right context are one of the signals that shape how brands are understood. See our AI & Search Visibility service.

Where is the authority gap?

Share the site and the competitors you're measured against. We'll show where the authority gap is.

Talk to an SEO specialist